Aisha/Nabu, Pt. 2: Nabu Was a Genderbent Aisha

I said this about Nabu at the end of the last post: “Rather, [Rainbow] created him because of a dilemma in Winx season three.”

Imagine Secret of the Lost Kingdom was the finale of Winx Club, since it wrapped up the main plot with Bloom finding her birth parents and saving Domino. This means season three was the last season. We all know Rainbow planned to stop there.

Winx season 2, episode 1: Aisha (Layla)

Aisha debuted in Winx season two, but Rainbow didn’t give her a love interest. (Would have been the best time to introduce Nex, but oh well.) You know the rules: a Winx can’t be single for more than one season.

But Winx Club only had one season left. That complicated things. For starters, it meant we’d never see Aisha and her boyfriend as a couple for a full season.

Let me repeat that: we’d never see Aisha and her boyfriend as a couple for a full season. That’s the dilemma. In this retcon of Winx Club history, Aisha and Nabu are the only couple who never dated onscreen.

That meant their love story had to accomplish two things:

  1. Introduce a love interest we’d care about, even though we’d barely get to see him as her boyfriend
  2. Convince us their relationship might work out, even though Rainbow would never develop it

Aisha and Male Aisha

How did the writers solve this dilemma? They threw Aisha into an arranged marriage to a genderbent version of herself.

Disagree? Tell me — if you literally genderbent Aisha, would “he” be that different from Nabu?

Disagree? Then tell me — if you literally turned Aisha into a guy, would “he” be that different from Nabu? No. “He” would:

  • Still be from Andros
  • Still be rich — and since Nabu was a prince in the Winx comics, “he” would still be royalty
  • Have a nearly identical backstory
  • Still like the same things (water sports, “The New Waves” band, etc.)

“He” would also still have magic powers, but since fairies are female in Winx Club, “he” would have to be a different type of magic being. What’s the closest thing to a male fairy in this series? A wizard.

Rainbow didn’t hide what they were doing. Aisha and Nabu frequently remarked on how similar they were, and after he told his backstory to the Winx, Bloom said, “Just like Aisha.” Bloom did the same thing in season four with Roxy. Twice, she told her, “You’re so much like me!” She also thought it a few times. Lampshading much?

On my other blog, I wrote a post about why Nabu was a Soul Mate Sue (a.k.a. Relationship Sue). The term came from an article about Mary Sues on a fanfiction site called Tokio Hotel Fiction. One tip to avoid writing a Soul Mate Sue relationship was to not give the love interest everything in common with their partner.

“But Nabu didn’t have everything in common with her,” you say. “He had a different personality. He was calmer, wiser, more polite…”

Yeah, better than her, which made no sense. Aisha’s childhood left her with social awkwardness, loner tendencies, and separation anxiety. But despite having a similar upbringing, Nabu turned out fine! He had none of the flaws or internal struggles she had.

That’s because his backstory only mattered for his role as Aisha’s love interest. It didn’t shape his own character — his personality, his opinions of the world, etc. — and it didn’t influence his interactions with other characters. This is common with Mary Sues. They often have tragic or difficult pasts that never hold them back in life, physically or emotionally. After all, they must be perfect no matter what.

In Nabu’s case, since he had the same backstory, we extended the empathy we felt for Aisha towards him. And since we think having everything in common equals perfect compatibility, we assumed their relationship could last. Plus, this was an arranged marriage, so we expected them to get married someday.

Disney Princess Plots

So why doesn’t the Winx fandom see Nabu as a Soul Mate Sue or a copy of Aisha? Why did we fall for Rainbow’s laziness?

Because we’re used to these types of love stories. Tokio Hotel Fiction called them “Disney princess plots”, and they are. Most Disney princess movies are like this:

  1. The princess meets her prince.
  2. They fall madly in love in a couple days — or a couple hours. It’s usually first love for both of them (just like Aisha and Nabu), and Disney wants us to believe it’s “true love”, not infatuation or anything else.
  3. They survive an adventure together.
  4. They get married and live “happily ever after”.

This works for a quick love story with no development, but not for a more natural relationship that gradually blossoms and deepens. Unfortunately, Rainbow didn’t have time to give Aisha that type of relationship, so they had to cut corners.

Final Thoughts

I’ve already talked about one drawback of Aisha and Nabu’s love story. She had an abnormal and restrictive childhood, and she left Andros to escape it. What she needed wasn’t someone exactly like her, but someone different to balance her life out with some normalcy.

Winx season 3: Aisha crying
Nabu didn’t ruin her life, but he ruined her story.

But that’s not the biggest problem. Aisha didn’t have a character goal, right? Nabu made things worse. He nullified what little plot she had to build on.

I’ll explain next time.

Series Navigation
<< Aisha and Nabu: Why Their Relationship Clashed With Her Story
Aisha/Nabu, Pt. 3: How Nabu Undermined Her Story >>
Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
NerdyPrincesses2 Mollz
NerdyPrincesses2 Mollz
November 6, 2019 3:23 pm

“Nabu didn’t ruin her life, but he ruined her story…” Yes, queen, bring those savage roasts!!!

Now that you mention it, all of this does make a lot of sense. I like this theory a lot. And when I looked at that comparison picture, I realized that Nabu and Aisha both have that little chunk of hair in front of their face! They really did just completely reuse her design and backstory. Wow.

Will N.
Will N.
November 7, 2019 8:57 am

I’m not sure if these roasts are the The Dragon’s Tide (what I like to call Aisha the fairy of after getting Bloomix) or Dragon Flames, but keep bringing them on.

Also could the End cameo be a clue to his Eventual End?

Will N.
Will N.
Reply to  Will N.
November 7, 2019 1:44 pm

Sorry wrong word. End of Episode Debut could have been a foreshadowing.

November 7, 2019 10:38 am

i don’t why but it sounds like they played us for fools or something

November 9, 2019 6:53 am

[…] season three, they prioritized a quick, convenient romance over her character growth and desires. The damage became permanent when they killed off Nabu in […]

December 3, 2019 11:58 am

[…] Why Rainbow Created Nabu […]

December 13, 2019 10:16 pm

[…] Why Rainbow Created Nabu […]

December 18, 2019 10:02 am

[…] Why Rainbow Created Nabu […]

October 9, 2020 6:04 pm

[…] Why Rainbow Created Nabu […]

June 27, 2021 7:14 am

[…] Actually, he will — as Aisha. I’ll merge his character with hers to fix a few problems with her story. It’s easier — and […]

July 1, 2021 7:39 am

[…] please. First, he ripped off his girlfriend’s backstory. Wait till you read my rewrite and see how much better Aisha’s story is if you merge her […]

October 17, 2021 1:20 pm

[…] most shallow because 1) he had no flaws, even though his backstory set up plenty for him; and 2) he was essentially a copy of Aisha, unlike the other guys, who are more distinct from their […]